Since 1950 it has been the practice for senior public servants to attend meetings of the Federal Cabinet as notetakers in order to prepare an accurate record of the decisions of Cabinet. The notes they take are intended purely as an aide-memoire for drafting the formal Cabinet decision after the meeting. The documents in which their notes are recorded are referred to as Cabinet notebooks.
The notebooks are not, nor are they intended to be, a verbatim account of Cabinet's discussions. While notetakers may record the discussion in any way they wish, and while the personal views of individual Ministers on particular issues may be recorded, by their nature the notebooks provide an incomplete record of the discussions.
Until 1941 the discussions of Ministers at Cabinet meetings were not recorded, but in 1941 a system of notetaking was introduced at meetings of the War Cabinet (see Fact Sheet 127 – War Cabinet records). This system was discontinued at the end of World War II, but was reintroduced in 1950 and has been in place ever since.
The earliest post-war notebooks date from 1950. While the arrangements for Cabinet notetaking have changed over time, a brief description of the system in place since the 1970s will illustrate how the system operates.
Three notetakers are present, the third of whom is required to take the fullest possible record of the meeting. This is used to produce the first draft of the decision, which is then passed to the two other notetakers (the most senior of whom, until 1996, was the Secretary of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet – since then the senior notetaker has been the Secretary to Cabinet, not the Secretary of the Department). The resulting Cabinet Minute provides the only formal (and 30 years later, public) record of the decision. Notetakers use their discretion in judging what to record in their notes, but they are required to take a full record of any conflict of interest declared by a Minister, and any request by Ministers that their dissent from a Cabinet decision be recorded.
As one would expect of notes hurriedly recorded during discussion, the notebooks contain a variety of styles and handwriting, some of which are almost illegible. Cabinet notebooks contain detail that is not recorded in the formal Cabinet decision. By comparing a Cabinet decision with the corresponding Cabinet notebook, it is sometimes possible to obtain a fuller picture of Cabinet's deliberations on a particular issue.
A detailed history of the operations of the Cabinet since 1901 is contained in the 1983–84 annual report of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet – The Development of Cabinet Procedures in Australia.
By convention, discussions by Ministers in the Cabinet room have been regarded as absolutely confidential. The convention of Cabinet confidentiality is seen as making possible complete frankness in Cabinet discussions, including the free expression by Ministers of differing opinions and views. Whatever the private views of Ministers, Cabinet solidarity requires that once a decision has been reached, it will be publicly supported by all Ministers.
Until 1994 it was argued that Cabinet notebooks should not be publicly released because if Ministers knew that details of the private views they expressed in the Cabinet room were to be released, this would inhibit the traditional frankness and freedom of expression in Cabinet meetings. These concerns were set aside in 1994 when the Archives Act was amended to make Cabinet notebooks available for public access for the first time. The notebooks are unique in that they are only made publicly available after 50 years rather than the standard 30 years governing Commonwealth government records (including other Cabinet records see Fact Sheet 34 – Cabinet records).
Cabinet notebooks that are more than 50 years old are publicly available. These comprise
Title or description of records | Date | Series & item no. |
War Cabinet and Advisory War Council | ||
War Cabinet and Advisory War Council notebooks
| 1941–46 | |
War Cabinet notebooks
| 1940–46 | A5954,
|
Advisory War Council notebooks
| 1940–45 | A5954,
|
Cabinet Office | ||
Cabinet notebooks
| 1950–95 | |
You can obtain more information about the record series listed above (and the items within the series) from RecordSearch, the Archives database. Follow the links in the series lists to go directly to information on that series. You can also use RecordSearch to find out about the agencies that created the records and to locate more records on your subject. You might also explore PhotoSearch to find out if there are photos pertaining to your subject.
Further information about records of Cabinet held by the National Archives is available from the following Fact Sheets:
RecordSearch and PhotoSearch are available online or in all Archives reading rooms. Reference staff are available in the reading rooms to help you, or email ref@naa.gov.au.
Comments or other feedback can be sent to archives@naa.gov.au
updated December 2006